With a push from his roommate after losing his job, David (Joe Boyd) hires an attractive life coach named Joyce (Rebecca St. James) to get his life back on track. When he accompanies Joyce's volunteer group to a retirement home, David discovers that his manipulative ex-boss and fellow volunteer, William, has a crush on Joyce, too. There, a crafty retiree encourages the pair to face one another for her heart. To hold his ground, David begrudgingly attends an open mic night hosted by Joyce where the inspiring words of a poet challenge him to ponder the existence of God and propel him further down the path of finding himself.
As his rivalry with William escalates, David makes a decision that jeopardizes his relationship with Joyce. With nowhere else to turn, David resorts to the community of retirees and discovers that sometimes finding yourself takes a search party.