As Hurleyville’s annual cupcake eating contest grows near, Kyle (Austin Battles) is put to the ultimate test. Although small in stature, he comes from a long line of cupcake eating champions. Kyle feels intense pressure to win this contest as he competes against Riley (Josh Maguire), who is trying to sabotage the competition.
The girls of Hurleyville are having a blast at Hazel’s slumber party, until they begin to play a new video game titled “Predictions”. This crazy game predicts their future and unfortunately the future isn’t looking too bright for any of them.
Meanwhile, Mark Collins (Will Gray), finds himself lured in by Hurleyville’s most successful and persuasive used car salesman, Arnie Delbert (Trey Harper). Mark is convinced he deserves a new sports car as his wife, Rebekah (Sarah Gray), tries to convince him there is something suspicious about Arnie.
Will Kyle find the strength to rise to the occasion or will he crack under the mounting pressure? Will the girls realize that nothing has control over their lives except for God or will their friendships be destroyed forever? Will Mark seek God’s guidance in this important decision or will Arnie’s mesmerizing salesmanship lead Mark down the wrong path?