After getting an "A" on her sixth grade final exam, Mary (Katherine McNamara) is rewarded with a puppy. Experiencing the love of this little puppy, and seeing several of her adult friends single and unhappy, Mary believes that placing two people together with the assistance of some loveable puppies will result in a happy relationships. With the help of her Aunt Karen (Dee Wallace) and Cameron Banks, (Jeff Fahey), the three of them become self described matchmaking angels, while along the way, Aunt Karen and Cameron, not only become accomplices in their scheme but also get "matched". As her success ratio continues, Mary utilizes her new matchmaking angels to carry out the biggest and most important plan, to bring her own parents back together again.
Seen through the eyes of a young girl on the verge of womanhood, Mary discovers that puppy love is more than just a trip to the animal shelter. This story illustrates how the lives of six people can be changed with a little help from a pre-teen matchmaker and three adorable puppies.