Michelle Taylor is living a lie. She's not who her family in Lancaster County believes she is. The Lapps were searching for their long-lost granddaughter when they came across Michelle and she assumed the identity of Sara Murray. Michelle was once homeless and hopeless, now she has come to love her Amish friends and even considers the idea of romance among them.
When Michelle stumbles across a an old blue jar in a barn filled with slips of paper with anonymous thoughts, quotes, and prayers she finds it encouraging for her budding faith. At the same time, she feels convicted. How can she tell the truth without hurting those she has come to love?